I was going to say Almunia however our resident goalkeeping expert Peter assured us that he was excellent and who are we to differ?

So Reyes then. As much as I loved the little gypo, it's hard to argue that given Wenger's reputation for spotting talent at the time, and given all the stories re how much we scouted him and what Wenger thought of him, in the end it was very surprising that he wasn't quite a bit better than he really was.