PDA

View Full Version : That India Best Test XI, no GinGan?


redgunamo
09-26-2016, 11:37 AM
Is Dhoni really a better captain?
Luis Anaconda
09-26-2016, 11:43 AM
Is Dhoni really a better captain?

Well he wouldn't get in as a batsman so someone has to captain them. Slightly surprised Sachin only got 73% of the votes. Not many players from the last century got a look in though
Burney
09-26-2016, 11:49 AM
Well he wouldn't get in as a batsman so someone has to captain them. Slightly surprised Sachin only got 73% of the votes. Not many players from the last century got a look in though

Sorry, but how did Yuvraj get in? No Harbhajan seems harsh also. Didn't like the guy, but his record would seem to demand inclusion.
Ash
09-26-2016, 11:53 AM
No Harbhajan seems harsh also. Didn't like the guy, but his record would seem to demand inclusion.

Only Singhs when he's winning.
redgunamo
09-26-2016, 11:55 AM
Well he wouldn't get in as a batsman so someone has to captain them. Slightly surprised Sachin only got 73% of the votes. Not many players from the last century got a look in though

Right. Good points.
Luis Anaconda
09-26-2016, 12:11 PM
Sorry, but how did Yuvraj get in? No Harbhajan seems harsh also. Didn't like the guy, but his record would seem to demand inclusion.


Popular man - rather ridiculous on his Test record. Harbajan was indeed a good bowler but Ashwin's figures are pretty impressive (though no one seems able to play spin these days, which helps). Would have Vengsarkar in above Laxman as well.