Good Morning Arsenal fans. Today's topic. Who in your opinion is the most overated Arsenal player?

[Pat Vegas]

in the past and present?

And why?

[Pokster]

['Neg]

[Rich]

[Nicosia Gooner]

[Rich]

[Sir Charlie of Nicholas]

[Pokster]

[Pat Vegas]

One game where he kept scoring against Kos.
The rest were all misses.

Though there is a highlight video of him playing for Arsenal and he looks amazing.

Don't trust youtube at all.

[Rich]

[Pat Vegas]

but something about him I didn't like.

But I loved him at the same time.

[Pokster]

[Nicosia Gooner]

[Pokster]

and yes, he was an exceptional player but I always felt a bit meh when things didn't go his way and I felt he went missing for a lot of games..... it is only my opinion and I am still very happy he played for us, just thought he could have been even better for us

[Pat Vegas]

It's very strange. I can remember weird details of all sorts of things.

I will hear a song on a radio and say oh that's the song that was playing in the taxi from the airport when we were in LA.

'How do you remember these things!'

[Rich]

more scuffed misses than shots on target, let alone goals.

Some AWIMBers poured scourn upon me for criticising him :-(

I see he has got 5 goals for Palace in nigh on 30 games this season.

[The Tony]

[Pat Vegas]

[Nicosia Gooner]

[Pokster]

[Pokster]

[Nicosia Gooner]

that is why I gave mine!

[Maravilloso Marvo]

You are stating that Bergkamp is not a 10 as people rate him, but merely an 8. The most overrated players are likely to be those rated 6 or 7 who are infact a 2 or 3.

Unless you are weighting the 1-10 scale where the difference between 9 and 10 is a lot bigger than the difference between 2 and 3.

[PSRB]

we were discussing this very same point on Sunday

Of all Premier League players ever, the answer is clearly Tim Cahill

[Pokster]

and that is my opinion, fine if you don't agree.

[Pokster]

some portray him as

[Maravilloso Marvo]

And you can't think of one player who was a 4 instead of a 7? Or a 3 instead of a 6?

[Maravilloso Marvo]

[dismalswamp]

[PSRB]

so guess it's what they see on the pitch and in training. I agree with you though, over-rated

[Pokster]

[Sir Charlie of Nicholas]

[Maravilloso Marvo]

post?

[Maravilloso Marvo]

under the expectation, then that is fine.

I mean it is strange that you can't think of anyone, but fine.

[PET]

Cant believe someone said Bergkamp whos probably in the top 3 in assists in the Premier League history...

[Pokster]

who in your opinion were mover over rated than Bergkamp, but in my opinion he wasn't the God like player that he is portrayed... so sorry you disagree with me, I await your players

[Pokster]

unfortunately some on here don't grasp that concept

[PET]

so you see, you cannot be overrating an appropriately overrated top player ..

[Berni]

[Pokster]

[PET]

[David Pleat AHADF (Royal Welsher and monkey lover)]

[redgunamo]

it's why you have them in the first place.

[Brentwood]

[Mack]

[One Wilf Copping]

I mean, seriously, all that Safe Hands™ crap, please...

Yes, he was good and an improvement on John Lukic, but not a huge improvement.

Jimmy Rimmer was better.

:hide:

[goonergaz]