Click here for Arsenal FC news and reports

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 18 of 18

Thread: In the same paragraph, Arseblog has said City's equaliser was offside but that our

  1. #11
    Quote Originally Posted by SWv2 View Post
    A wonderful game which brings forth different opinions.

    I don’t think Silva’s presence in any way affected Cech’s inability to stop the shot given it was low to his left and Silva was moving in from his right, and indeed at a very late stage in the developing move.

    There is indeed too much ambiguity surrounding a player interfering, or not, with play and as such I am more than willing to accept this.
    2015/16Interpretation:

    "Players have previously been allowed to be in offside positions if they were not an "active" part of play; to be offside a player had to touch the ball. Referees' chief Mike Riley says the International Football Association Board (IFAB), the sport's law making body, introduced a change meaning anybody in an offside position making a play for the ball, being close to the ball or having an impact on an opponent would be deemed offside - even if they did not make contact."

    http://www.getwestlondon.co.uk/sport...201516-9879398

  2. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by Ash View Post
    Discussing the interpretation of the laws of the game does not necessarily equate to making excuses. That would reflect poorly on our logic to assume such a connection.
    Yes, but when one says "us" one may have been referring to the larger family and not simply us as is "us".

    I don't think we lost the game on rule interpretation, I think we lost as we played very poorly.

  3. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Ash View Post
    2015/16Interpretation:

    "Players have previously been allowed to be in offside positions if they were not an "active" part of play; to be offside a player had to touch the ball. Referees' chief Mike Riley says the International Football Association Board (IFAB), the sport's law making body, introduced a change meaning anybody in an offside position making a play for the ball, being close to the ball or having an impact on an opponent would be deemed offside - even if they did not make contact."

    http://www.getwestlondon.co.uk/sport...201516-9879398
    As before I don’t believe his presence in any way impeded or affected Cech’s inability to stop the shot.

    Fuming (mildly annoyed) is what I would be had such a decision gone against us for example, always a common sense way of judging these things I find. At the time for example I did not even react to the Spaniard’s presence.

  4. #14
    Quote Originally Posted by SWv2 View Post
    Yes, but when one says "us" one may have been referring to the larger family and not simply us as is "us".

    I don't think we lost the game on rule interpretation, I think we lost as we played very poorly.
    Of course we lost because we played poorly. The fact that both of their goals were, arguably, offside does not alter the fact that we were **** and deserved to lose.

  5. #15
    Quote Originally Posted by SWv2 View Post
    As before I don’t believe his presence in any way impeded or affected Cech’s inability to stop the shot.

    Fuming (mildly annoyed) is what I would be had such a decision gone against us for example, always a common sense way of judging these things I find. At the time for example I did not even react to the Spaniard’s presence.
    Had such a decision gone against us I would expect you to accept the decision of the officials and move on, as I have never seen you express fume or mild annoyance at any decision against us.

  6. #16
    Quote Originally Posted by Ash View Post
    Had such a decision gone against us I would expect you to accept the decision of the officials and move on, as I have never seen you express fume or mild annoyance at any decision against us.
    I suppose you are correct here.

    I see it as futile to rage after the event. It is one of the many great personal skills I have which I am very grateful for that upon final whistle I simply move on as opposed to others who for their own reasons may allow such events to spoil their day and/or evening.

  7. #17
    Quote Originally Posted by Ash View Post
    2015/16Interpretation:

    "Players have previously been allowed to be in offside positions if they were not an "active" part of play; to be offside a player had to touch the ball. Referees' chief Mike Riley says the International Football Association Board (IFAB), the sport's law making body, introduced a change meaning anybody in an offside position making a play for the ball, being close to the ball or having an impact on an opponent would be deemed offside - even if they did not make contact."

    http://www.getwestlondon.co.uk/sport...201516-9879398

    hmmmm Mike Riley... hmmmmm
    "Scoring a goal is better than sex" - Whoever said that was sticking it to the wrong woman

  8. #18
    Quote Originally Posted by SWv2 View Post
    A wonderful game which brings forth different opinions.

    I don’t think Silva’s presence in any way affected Cech’s inability to stop the shot given it was low to his left and Silva was moving in from his right, and indeed at a very late stage in the developing move.

    There is indeed too much ambiguity surrounding a player interfering, or not, with play and as such I am more than willing to accept this.

    In summary this goal was really poor by Cech and our scrambling around for excuses and blame to apportion simply reflects poorly on us.

    Wenger out!

    One could argue that Monreal could have done more to keep Sterling at bay. Perhaps keep him outside the penalty area as long as possible and allow the other defenders to get back into place. Once Sterling got into that shooting position there was not really much Cech could do. It was low and in the corner. Few keepers would have saved that.

    On the other side, what a great ball from De Bruyne in to Sterling's path.
    "Scoring a goal is better than sex" - Whoever said that was sticking it to the wrong woman

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •