Henry was dithering over a contract, Bergkamp was on the verge of retirement, Pires and Ljungberg were passed their best. Reyes was well Reyes. Adebayor was also there of course. So at the 2006 stage he can make an argument, which is actually what he says - at their peak of course it isn't even a contest, but I am sure you will agree that the 25-year-old Walcott who never plays is better than the the 16-year-old Walcott who never plays