Impossible to answer. I think our moral framework needs to be fine-tuned first.
We can start by acknowledging that free will is an illusion.
My Coutts card doesn’t have contactless, so I get to annoy people in the queue twice
It's not about ethics, I think. It's simply that we're a nation of pirates, blackguards, violent drunks and scoundrels. And, most importantly, proud of it.
So when such questions arise, the major part of us will instinctively side with the weaker, more vulnerable party, the underdog.